|
Richard Oberdorfer's "Open Web"
Quiz
[Richard Oberdorfer, head of the history
department at Norfolk Academy, prepared this quiz in the summer of 1996
to introduce a group of high school juniors to the basics of using the
World Wide Web for research -- finding and evaluating sources on the Web.
His introductory section is based on the search engine "Excite!"
as configured at the time. Since search engines as well as the resources
listed undergo periodic overhaul, it is recommended that this introductory
section be reviewed and edited, if necessary, by the instructor before
using this quiz. (Excite, for example, has just dumped all the links that
would make questions 1-8 relevant; we hope to update with a search on
Altavista, Lycos,
Yahoo, or Infoseek
in the near future.) Answers to the questions about Richard III and fifteenth
century life can all be found on the Richard III Society site. If you
are using web-based instruction in your course, you are welcome to download
this quiz to your own site and amend as appropriate.]
Select NET SEARCH. There are a number of Search
Services from which you may choose. Let's select the one called "EXCITE".
When it asks what you're looking for, type "King
Richard III", and then click on "Search".
Choices will appear, ten at a time. The word
"confidence" suggests how much of an entry relates to the
subject requested.
Select the first one: "Richard III and His
Nephews".
1. What is the main reason the author
believes that Henry Tudor is a more likely perpetrator of the alleged
murders of the Princes?
2. Does the author document sources for these
conclusions by supplying reference citations?
3. Continue to scroll to the end of the article.
See the various entries that begin "Return to. . ."? This
article is part of a larger collection of entries. Retrace these and
find out who the author of the article is. Look for the author's "Homepage".
4. Find the author's autobiography. Does this
suggest that the Richard III article should be considered SERIOUS
scholarship?
Now, go back to the choices found for you by
EXCITE.
5. The next two choices deal with Shakespeare
and his plays. If you wish to do HISTORICAL research on King Richard's
life, should you look at these? Why, or why not?
6. The next entry is titled "Richard III
Page". Click on that. What is the name of the organization responsible
for this entry?
7. Does the text-description of the organization
suggest that this group's intention is to defend Richard's name or
charge him with royal crimes?
Go back to the EXCITE-choices page. Continue
to the bottom of the list. Since Stephen King is unlikely to be a scholarly
historical source(!), and we want more than geneologies, let's click
on "Next Documents".
8. The next screen covers essentially
literature; but six entries down the page, there is a reference to the
"Richard III Society". Is that the same organization we just
discovered in Question #6?
To find out more about the Richard III Society,
scroll to the bottom of the page and click on "New Search".
The second entry provided by this new search describes the "Richard
III Society Homepage".
9. Does the description provided suggest
that this organization advocates a single view concerning Richard III's
guilt or innocence?
Click on the Richard III Society Homepage. The
Homepage identifies the organization as the "American Branch".
10. The original name of the parent
society was the Fellowship of the White Boar. Why did they choose "White
Boar"?
11. Regarding the film RICHARD III starring
Sir Ian McKellen, does the Richard III Society believe that the 1930's
setting of the film REINFORCES the negative impression of Richard
that is commonly held today?
The Richard III Society Homepage provides a number
of links to more specific sites. Use these to answer the following questions:
12. A> Name one source from which Shakespeare
probably gleaned the "facts" upon which he based his play
about Richard III.
B> Name the title and author of the article that provides this information.
C> Based on the information provided, would you consider this source
to be a scholarly one? Why or why not?
D> Look at the "Netsite" at the top of your screen. What is
the ADDRESS of the source of this information?
13. Name one academic discussion list available
on the Internet that could provide information relevant to the study
of Richard III.
14. Anyone researching medieval topics should
be familiar with "the Labyrinth". What is "the Labyrinth"
and where is it located?
15. A> What popular sports in the fifteenth-century
had distinctly MILITARY overtones?
B> Name the title and author of the article that provides this information.
C> Based on the information provided, would you consider this source
to be a scholarly one? Why or why not?
D> Look at the "Netsite" at the top of your screen. What
is the ADDRESS of the source of this information?
16. A> While bread was a common food in the
Middle Ages, how did the bread eaten by one class differ from that
eaten by another?
B> Name the title and author of the article that provides this information.
C> Based on the information provided, would you consider this source
to be a scholarly one? Why or why not?
D> Look at the "Netsite" at the top of your screen. What
is the ADDRESS of the source of this information?
17. Name one book to which one might turn to
find information on medieval DRESS.
18. What anonymous poem, covering Richard's
final battle, was probably written at a time when the battle was a
living memory?
19. A> Some historians suggest that the Battle
of Bosworth was fought closer to another town a mile and a half away
from the traditional site. What is that town?
B> Name the title and author of the article that provides this information.
C> Based on the information provided, would you consider this source
to be a scholarly one? Why or why not?
D> Look at the "Netsite" at the top of your screen. What
is the ADDRESS of the source of this information?
20. A> According to legend, there was a note
found in the Duke of Norfolk's tent suggesting (accurately) that what
nobleman would betray Richard III in the pending Battle of Bosworth?
B> Look at the "Netsite" at the top of your screen. What
is the ADDRESS of the source of this information?
21. Name one foreign (non-English) primary-source
account of th Battle of Bosworth.
22. Which of the following historians believe
that Richard III is guilty of the murder of the Princes in the Tower,
and which historians do not believe that he is guilty?
A> Desmond Seward
B> Alison Weir
C> Paul Murray Kendall
D> Jeremy Potter
E> Giles St. Aubyn
23. Give three complete bibliographical references
that one might research to gather information on the fate of the Princes
whom Richard allegedly killed.
24. If a teacher wishes to design lessons around
Richard III, there are specific guides available on the Internet.
Name one.
25. Name two popular novels written about Richard
III.
26. Name one play -- besides that of Shakespeare
-- that employs Richard III as its central character.
|